Does Arthur Morgan Die of Tuberculosis? Understanding the Tragic End
Yes, in the storyline of Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan tragically dies of tuberculosis (TB), contracted during a mission involving a debt collection. This disease, coupled with the relentless pursuit of the law and Micah Bell’s betrayal, seals his fate.
The Unfolding Tragedy: Arthur’s Diagnosis
The heartbreaking narrative of Arthur Morgan’s demise is a cornerstone of Red Dead Redemption 2‘s emotional depth. The gradual decline of his health, from initial symptoms to his eventual death, paints a grim picture of the realities of life in the late 19th century. This was a time when diseases like tuberculosis were rampant and often fatal.
How Arthur Contracts TB: A Turning Point
- The Debt Collection Mission: Arthur’s fateful encounter with Thomas Downes, a sickly farmer struggling to repay his debts, becomes the catalyst.
- The Physical Confrontation: During the rough handling of Downes, Arthur is coughed on directly, exposing him to the tuberculosis bacteria.
- The Initial Symptoms: It takes time for the disease to manifest, initially appearing as a persistent cough and fatigue.
Symptoms and Progression of Tuberculosis in Arthur
The progression of tuberculosis in Arthur Morgan is depicted realistically, showcasing the debilitating effects of the disease:
- Persistent Cough: A hacking cough that gradually worsens.
- Fatigue and Weakness: Reduced stamina and inability to perform tasks with his usual vigor.
- Weight Loss: Noticeable thinning of his physique.
- Night Sweats: Episodes of profuse sweating during sleep.
- Bloody Cough (Hemoptysis): A clear sign of advanced lung damage.
- Shortness of Breath: Difficulty breathing even during minimal exertion.
The Impact on Arthur’s Character and Story
Arthur’s illness serves as a powerful catalyst for his character development. Facing his mortality, he begins to re-evaluate his life, his actions, and his role within the Van der Linde gang.
- Increased Empathy: He becomes more compassionate and willing to help those in need.
- Questioning Loyalty: Arthur begins to question Dutch’s leadership and the direction of the gang.
- Seeking Redemption: He strives to make amends for his past misdeeds.
Historical Accuracy of Tuberculosis in Red Dead Redemption 2
Red Dead Redemption 2 accurately portrays the historical context of tuberculosis in the late 1800s:
- High Prevalence: TB was a widespread and devastating disease.
- Limited Treatment: Medical options were limited and often ineffective.
- Social Stigma: The disease carried a social stigma, leading to isolation and discrimination.
Alternate Theories and Interpretations
While the game explicitly states that Arthur Morgan dies of tuberculosis, some players have proposed alternate or supplementary theories:
- Stress and Trauma: The constant stress and trauma Arthur endured may have weakened his immune system, making him more susceptible to TB.
- Micah’s Role: Some theorize that Micah may have intentionally hastened Arthur’s death, although this is not explicitly shown in the game.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What type of tuberculosis did Arthur Morgan have?
It’s most likely that Arthur contracted pulmonary tuberculosis, which affects the lungs. This is the most common form of the disease and aligns with the symptoms he exhibits, such as a persistent cough and bloody sputum.
Could Arthur have survived tuberculosis in that era?
Survival was unlikely. Treatment options for tuberculosis in the late 19th century were extremely limited. Rest, fresh air, and good nutrition were often recommended, but these were rarely sufficient to cure the disease, especially in advanced stages.
Did Arthur know he was going to die?
Yes. After his diagnosis, Arthur visited Sister Calderón, a nun who provided him with spiritual guidance. He was fully aware that his condition was terminal and that his time was limited.
How long did Arthur live after contracting tuberculosis?
The timeframe is not precisely defined, but it appears to be several months. The game shows a progression of symptoms over this period, culminating in his death near the end of the story.
Was Arthur’s death necessary for the story?
Many argue yes. Arthur’s death is a pivotal moment in Red Dead Redemption 2‘s narrative. It underscores the themes of mortality, redemption, and the fading of the Wild West. It also sets the stage for John Marston’s story in the epilogue.
Did Thomas Downes die from tuberculosis too?
Yes. Thomas Downes eventually succumbs to tuberculosis, highlighting the devastating impact of the disease on families and communities during that time.
Is it possible to prevent contracting TB in the game?
No, Arthur’s contracting TB is a scripted event within the game’s storyline. There is no way to avoid it, regardless of player choices or actions.
What is the significance of Arthur’s last ride?
Arthur’s last ride is a powerful and emotional scene. Depending on the player’s honor level, it reflects either his attempt at redemption or his descent into despair. It’s a symbolic representation of his final journey.
Did other characters in the game know about Arthur’s condition?
Yes. Eventually, key members of the Van der Linde gang, including John Marston and Sadie Adler, became aware of Arthur’s illness and its severity. Dutch’s awareness is debatable, but it is implied that he knew.
How accurate is Red Dead Redemption 2‘s portrayal of tuberculosis?
The game’s depiction of tuberculosis is generally considered to be quite accurate, particularly in terms of the symptoms, progression, and lack of effective treatment options available at the time.
What resources were available for people with tuberculosis in the late 1800s?
Resources were scarce. Sanatoriums, which offered rest and fresh air, were beginning to emerge, but access was limited, and they were often ineffective in curing the disease.
Does Red Dead Redemption 2 glorify or downplay the severity of tuberculosis?
The game does not glorify the disease. Arthur’s suffering and eventual death realistically depict the devastating impact of tuberculosis, demonstrating the lack of medical advancements during that era.